OPINIONCOMMENTARYSUGARY DRINKS TAX
Cashing in is not a reform
Sugar tax, higher alcohol duties, an alcopop duty up to 15 per cent: anyone who wants to place an additional burden on citizens and businesses must explain what it achieves, what it costs and who does the work. Ten questions for the federal government.
By Andreas W. Herb, Founder and CEO MBG Group, Paderborn
10 minutes read11 sources0 correctionsDisclosure
Share
Contents
1 day
before the cabinet dealt with it, the regulatory control council received the final draft
Statement of 16 October 2026[1]
€19.4m
new cost per year for the federal government and business
Estimate by the finance ministry[1]
400
additional customs staff that the customs officers’ union considers necessary
The proposal allows for 200, to be offset internally[2]
20 years
lie behind 3.85 billion euros of savings
Model calculation, not a saving per year[4]
Protecting health deserves better policy than a new tax with open questions. Anyone who wants to place an additional burden on citizens and businesses must be able to explain what it achieves, what it costs and who does the work.
The federal government is planning two things. Under its draft of the 2027 budget accompanying act, alcohol, sparkling wine, intermediate products and alcopop duty were to rise by 20 per cent.[3] On top of that comes a new tax on sugared drinks.[8] It did not come as a bill of its own, but as drafting assistance for an amendment by the coalition parliamentary groups to the same act.[1] On 9 November 2026 the Bundestag finance committee heard experts on it.[11]
On 12 November 2026 the finance committee approved the act with amendments. The sugar tax is to come half a year later, at the start of 2028, and in three tiers instead of two. Sparkling wine is exempt from the increase. In return, the alcopop duty is to apply in future to mixed drinks of up to 15 per cent alcohol, at a lower rate than planned.[9] The Bundestag still has to vote. Ten questions are open.
1. Check first, then cash in. Not the other way round.
The national regulatory control council examines for the federal government what costs a law causes. It received the final draft of the sugary drinks tax only one day before the cabinet dealt with it. This, it writes, prevented it from exercising its statutory mandate.[1]
„Eine Überprüfung der Regelungsfolgen im Sinne guter Rechtsetzung war nicht abschließend möglich.“
Translation: A conclusive review of the consequences of the regulation in the sense of good lawmaking was not possible.
The council recommends introducing a new excise duty through the regular legislative procedure and involving the businesses and associations affected.[1] This is not the drinks industry speaking, but an independent body that advises the federal government. No such involvement took place before the bill was introduced, writes the customs officers’ union BDZ.[2] My question: why should citizens pay for a law whose consequences could not be conclusively examined?
2. Anyone who promises success must say how it will be measured
Five years after its start the tax is to be reviewed. According to the findings of the regulatory control council, the aims, criteria and data basis of this review are not set out. On the benefit there is a single sentence: “The ministry has not set out any benefit.”[1]
That does not mean there can be no benefit. It means: the government must set it out comprehensibly for its specific plan instead of leaving the burden of proof to the public. My question: how will you measure in five years whether the tax has worked?
3. More alcohol, less duty: explain that to a teenager
A ready-mixed drink of spirits and lemonade with less than 10 per cent alcohol counts as an alcopop.[5] On it, the alcopop duty is payable in addition to the alcohol duty.[6][7] A 0.33 litre can at 9.9 per cent therefore carries 2.24 euros of excise duty today. The same can at 10.0 per cent carries 43 cents.
A duty that plunges by around 81 per cent despite more alcohol needs a better explanation than simply invoking the protection of minors. The detailed calculation is in the commentary The absurdity of the alcopop duty. My question: why is this false incentive not removed?
4. Moving the threshold does not fix the flawed reasoning
That is exactly what the finance committee decided. The alcopop duty is to apply in future to mixed drinks of up to 15 per cent alcohol. According to the amendment, a 0.33-litre can at 10 per cent will thus carry around 1 euro more.[9] That corresponds to around 30 euros of alcopop duty per litre of pure alcohol, a little over half of today’s rate.[6] Together with the higher alcohol duty[3] a new cliff emerges. By calculation, the can at 14.9 per cent would carry 2.26 euros of excise duty, the one at 15.1 per cent 78 cents.
| Case | Alcohol content | Pure alcohol per can | Duty per litre of pure alcohol | Excise duty per can |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Today, alcopop | 9.9 % vol | 32.67 ml | €68.53 | €2.24 |
| Today, not an alcopop | 10.0 % vol | 33.00 ml | €13.03 | €0.43 |
| Committee version, alcopop | 9.9 % vol | 32.67 ml | €45.94 | €1.50 |
| Committee version, alcopop | 14.9 % vol | 49.17 ml | €45.94 | €2.26 |
| Committee version, not an alcopop | 15.1 % vol | 49.83 ml | €15.64 | €0.78 |
Committee version of 12 November 2026, not yet adopted by the Bundestag. 2027 alcohol duty under the government bill: 15.64 euros per litre of pure alcohol. Alcopop duty: 30.30 euros, derived from the amendment’s statement that a can at 10 per cent would carry around 1 euro more; the legal text was not available. The calculation assumes that the other rules stay the same. Amounts rounded to the cent; they are not shop prices.
The jump would be smaller: around two thirds instead of around 81 per cent. But a jump would remain, only at 15 instead of 10 per cent alcohol. At the same time, the can at 9.9 per cent would be taxed less than today, at 1.50 instead of 2.24 euros. Anyone who moves the threshold to 15 per cent has not yet made a health policy reform. They have put the tax cliff in a different place.
5. “Offset internally” is not a magic trick
For the sugary drinks tax the proposal allows for 200 staff at customs and 23 at the federal IT service provider. This requirement is to be offset internally within staffing. The customs officers’ union BDZ considers around 400 additional staff at customs necessary. It demands that they really be added and not withdrawn from other customs tasks.[2]
Work does not disappear because it is written into a different organisation chart. My question: which customs tasks will get fewer staff if no additional staff come?
6. 19.4 million euros of cost a year is not cutting bureaucracy
For the new tax the finance ministry estimates around 16.9 million euros of cost per year at federal level and around 2.5 million euros of bureaucracy costs per year in business. The regulatory control council books this as a new burden of 19.4 million euros a year. On top of that come one-off costs of around 5.3 million euros at federal level and around 940,000 euros in businesses. Just under 2,300 businesses would in future need a permit for a tax warehouse.[1]
The customs officers’ union proposes examining a simpler model without tax warehouses and without duty suspension. The draft of a plastic packaging tax already manages without either.[2] My question: where is the cost comparison before a new procedure is built up?
7. Twenty years is not one year
A modelling study from 2023 calculates 3.85 billion euros less in treatment costs for a tax tiered by sugar content. That is the total over 20 years, from 2023 to 2043. It is not an annual saving for the health insurance funds. On average it would be around 190 million euros a year.[4]
The study also assumes that manufacturers cut the sugar in their drinks by 30 per cent, as was observed in Britain after the tax there was introduced.[4] Whether that happens to the same extent in Germany is open. Amelie Wuppermann, who supports the tax, also writes this in her statement for the Bundestag.[10]
That can justify prevention. It is not a short-term rescue plan for the health insurance funds. Anyone who argues with billions must state the time period just as prominently.
8. Cut first, then cut less: that is no savings miracle
According to the federal government, the revenue from the sugar tax is to reduce a previously planned cut in the federal subsidy to the health fund.[8] But a partly reversed cut is something different from less illness and lower treatment costs. Citizens are entitled to three separate accounts: tax revenue, subsidies and genuine savings in health costs.
9. Spare Sekt, burden mixed drinks: where is the medical logic?
The extension of the alcopop duty replaces the higher sparkling wine duty. The CDU/CSU parliamentary group justifies dropping it with the difficult situation of the winegrowers; the additional revenue from the extension is to offset the shortfall.[9] For the higher duty on Sekt, 65 million euros a year had been budgeted.[3] The SPD parliamentary group points out that drinks with more alcohol are more widespread today than when the duty was introduced.[9] That does not explain why Sekt of all things is spared. That may be a budget compromise. It does not provide a health policy justification.
10. Sugar does not become harmless because it sits in an exemption
Among the drinks to be exempt from the tax are pure fruit and vegetable juices, milk, oat and rice drinks, and alcohol-free alternatives to alcoholic drinks.[8] It does not follow that all drinks should be assessed in the same way. But it does follow that there is a duty to explain which exemptions are objectively necessary and how avoidance is prevented.
The customs officers’ union wants to scrap the exemption for juices without added sugar. Whether sugar is naturally present or added can often only be established through recipes, production records or laboratory analyses, it says.[2] My question: how is customs supposed to police these boundaries?
Three questions that must be answered before the start
To the finance minister: where is the complete net calculation, including administrative costs, shifts in sales and lower tax revenue elsewhere?
To the health policy makers: how many illnesses and which treatment costs does exactly this German rule prevent, and in which year? What is meant is not some model from another country.
To the coalition leaders: which verifiable conditions must be met before the tax starts? And what consequences will you draw if effect and revenue fall short of the promises?
Protecting health is too important for bad legislation. Anyone who demands new taxes must deliver more than good intentions: a clean calculation, clear aims and a procedure that works. How the budget can manage without new taxes is set out in the open proposal to the chancellor.
Andreas W. HerbFounder and CEO MBG Group, Paderborn
What I expressly do not claim
I do not claim that a sugar tax has no effect. There is scientific evidence, above all from Britain, that a tiered tax moves manufacturers to put less sugar in their recipes.[10] My criticism is directed at the design, examination and justification of this law. The large new workload at customs arises above all from the sugar tax; the mere increase in existing alcohol duties must be distinguished from it, and the customs officers’ union expressly welcomes the planned simplification of the alcopop procedure.[2] The amounts per can are excise duties, not shop prices.
METHOD
Method
Pure alcohol per can: 330 ml × alcohol content, for instance 330 ml × 9.9 % = 32.67 ml = 0.03267 litres.
Today below 10 %: alcohol duty 13.03 euros plus alcopop duty 55.50 euros = 68.53 euros per litre of pure alcohol; 0.03267 × 68.53 = 2.2389 euros, rounded 2.24 euros. At 10.0 % alcohol duty only: 0.033 × 13.03 = 0.4300 euros.
Committee version: alcopop duty derived from the amendment’s figure, 1 euro ÷ 0.033 litres of pure alcohol = 30.30 euros per litre. With the 2027 alcohol duty of 15.64 euros, that makes 45.94 euros per litre of pure alcohol. At 9.9 %: 0.03267 × 45.94 = 1.5009 euros. At 14.9 %: 0.04917 × 45.94 = 2.2589 euros. At 15.1 % alcohol duty only: 0.04983 × 15.64 = 0.7793 euros.
The jump: today (2.2389 − 0.4300) ÷ 2.2389 = 80.8 per cent, i.e. around 81 per cent; under the committee version (2.2589 − 0.7793) ÷ 2.2589 = 65.5 per cent, i.e. around two thirds. If the higher alcohol duty is counted within the one euro, the result is 27.69 euros of alcopop duty per litre and a jump of 63.4 per cent; that does not change the order of magnitude.
Cost: 16.9 million euros at federal level plus 2.5 million euros in business = 19.4 million euros a year, as also stated in the regulatory control council’s statement.
Savings: 3,850 million euros less in treatment costs over 20 years (study, Table 2, tiered tax) ÷ 20 = 192.5 million euros, so around 190 million euros a year. The study does not spread the savings evenly over the years; the average serves only to compare orders of magnitude.
CHECK
What was checked before publication
- All statements were checked against the originals on 11 November 2026: against the statement of the regulatory control council, against the statements of the customs officers’ union BDZ and of Amelie Wuppermann for the hearing in the Bundestag, against bill 21/7860, against the Alkopopsteuergesetz and the Alkoholsteuergesetz, against the federal government’s questions and answers and against the study in PLOS Medicine. On 13 November 2026 we updated the text to reflect the finance committee’s decision of the previous day.
- The Bundestag’s report does not give the new alcopop duty rate in euros. It quotes the amendment: a 0.33-litre can at 10 per cent will in future carry around 1 euro more. From this we derive around 30 euros per litre of pure alcohol. We did not have the legal text of the committee version. The author’s source material relied on a report in the FAZ for the extension; we were unable to access it and do not cite it as a source.
- The source material gave savings of around 3.8 billion euros. In its table the study shows 3.85 billion euros for the tiered tax; we use this value.
- The amounts per can are our own calculations under the law and the bill; the arithmetic is set out under “How we calculated”. The finance ministry and the coalition parliamentary groups were not asked for comment.
SOURCES
Sources
Every number in the text leads to its source. The origin is given at each entry: official, media report, trade association, institute or data portal. Titles stay in the original language, so that each document can still be found.
[1] Nationaler Normenkontrollrat, 16.10.2026
Stellungnahme NKR-Nr. 8281: Formulierungshilfe zum Haushaltsbegleitgesetz 2027, Entwurf eines Zuckergetränkesteuergesetzes (Seiten 1 bis 4)Official source↑ back to the text
[2] BDZ Deutsche Zoll- und Finanzgewerkschaft, 04.11.2026
Stellungnahme zum Haushaltsbegleitgesetz 2027 für die Anhörung im Finanzausschuss am 9. November 2026Trade association↑ back to the text
[3] Deutscher Bundestag, 07.09.2026
Drucksache 21/7860: Entwurf eines Haushaltsbegleitgesetzes 2027 (Artikel 1 bis 3, Finanztabelle)Official source↑ back to the text
[4] PLOS Medicine, 21.11.2023
Emmert-Fees u. a.: Projected health and economic impacts of sugar-sweetened beverage taxation in Germany (Tabelle 2)Institute or public body↑ back to the text
[5] Bundesministerium der Justiz, Stand 11.11.2026
§ 1 Alkopopsteuergesetz: Steuergegenstand (mehr als 1,2 und weniger als 10 Prozent vol)Official source↑ back to the text
[6] Bundesministerium der Justiz, Stand 11.11.2026
§ 2 Alkopopsteuergesetz: Steuertarif (5.550 Euro je Hektoliter reinen Alkohols)Official source↑ back to the text
[7] Bundesministerium der Justiz, Stand 11.11.2026
§ 2 Alkoholsteuergesetz: Steuertarif (Regelsatz 1.303 Euro je Hektoliter Alkohol)Official source↑ back to the text
[8] Die Bundesregierung, 14.10.2026
Fragen und Antworten: Zuckergetränkesteuer soll Gesundheitssystem entlastenOfficial source↑ back to the text
[9] Deutscher Bundestag, 12.11.2026
hib 935/2026: Finanzausschuss stimmt Verbrauchsteuer-Änderungen zuOfficial source↑ back to the text
[10] Universität Bayreuth, 09.11.2026
Prof. Dr. Amelie Wuppermann: Stellungnahme zur öffentlichen Anhörung des Finanzausschusses zum Haushaltsbegleitgesetz 2027Institute or public body↑ back to the text
[11] Deutscher Bundestag, 09.11.2026
Anhörung zum Haushaltsbegleitgesetz und zur Zuckergetränkesteuer im FinanzausschussOfficial source↑ back to the text
CORRECTIONS
Corrections
No corrections since publication on 13/11/2026. Every substantive change appears here with its date, reason and previous wording.
This page is opinion. Our fact checks are not.