OPINIONVIDEOALCOPOP DUTY
When the government will not learn and the party whip reduces members of parliament to wards: damage to our country, to politics, and massive damage to producers of cans, flavourings and grain
The guest commentary on the alcopop duty as a film in chapters, just under 13 minutes. Plus what the video does not show: who votes now, how free they are in doing so, and whom the extension hits besides the drinks manufacturers.
By Andreas W. Herb, Founder and CEO MBG Group, Paderborn
4 minutes read8 sources0 correctionsDisclosure
Share
Contents
In 2004 the alcopop duty was meant to protect young people, and its money was supposed to go into addiction prevention. For 2005 to 2007 the federal government budgeted 156 million euros from the whole segment and took in 22.7 million. In 2025 it refunded more than it collected. On 12 November 2026 the Bundestag finance committee decided to extend the duty to mixed drinks of up to 15 per cent.[1] The video tells this story in chapters; every figure appears with its source in the guest commentary.
What the video shows
| From minute | Chapter | What it is about |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | Opening | A Saturday evening in 2004 and the balance in three images: 156 million euros planned, 22.7 collected; in 2025 more refunded than collected; in 2026 the extension in five days |
| 1:33 | 1: 2004 | Intended as protection of minors: 5,550 euros of special duty per hectolitre of pure alcohol, around 84 cents per bottle, the money for prevention |
| 3:00 | 2: What came of it | Plan against reality 2005 to 2007, nothing left for prevention, the coalition confirms the finding |
| 5:00 | 3: 2026 | The extension up to 15 per cent, its reason, and five days from the news report to the decision |
| 6:48 | 4: Second mistake | The same calculation, only bigger: what is hoped for is more than seventy times the 2024 figure |
| 9:06 | 5: The damage | The tax meant to steer behaviour becomes a gap-filler; one alcohol, three rules; much effort, little return |
| 11:00 | 6: What needs to be done | Five steps while the Bundestag has not yet voted |
The opening begins with three six-packs that in 2004 cost 15.12 euros more at the checkout, 84 cents per bottle. Then the vodka bottle comes onto the table, and eight years later the emergency department is on screen: in 2012 children and young people aged between 10 and 19 were treated in hospital for alcohol poisoning 26,673 times, more often than in any other year.[8] The data do not show that the duty caused this: the rise began before 2004, and after 2012 the cases fell markedly.[8]
The Bundestag has yet to vote
So far the extension has only been approved in the finance committee.[1] The Bundestag still has to vote. It holds its final deliberations on the 2027 budget from 24 to 27 November.[2] After that the Bundesrat will deal with the act.
The Basic Law knows no party whip. Of the members of the Bundestag it says:
„Sie sind Vertreter des ganzen Volkes, an Aufträge und Weisungen nicht gebunden und nur ihrem Gewissen unterworfen.“
Translation: They shall be representatives of the whole people, not bound by orders or instructions and responsible only to their conscience.
Andreas W. Herb expects the coalition’s members of parliament to vote nonetheless as their parliamentary group dictates. They will then be voting on an extension that was not part of any hearing[7], that was approved in committee three days after the hearing[1], and for which no impact assessment has been published. Anyone who votes like that is following an instruction, not an examination of their own. That is what the title means by “reduced to wards” (entmündigt). Only the vote will show whether individual members break ranks.
Whom else the extension hits
It is not only the manufacturers of the drinks who are hit. The industry association BWS fears that ready-to-drink mixed drinks of up to 15 per cent will disappear from the German market entirely; whole business models would face the end.[6] After 2004 exactly that has happened once before: drinks below 10 per cent have, in the words of the coalition parliamentary groups, “almost entirely disappeared from the market”.[4]
Such a drink is not made in a single business. It consists of alcohol, flavourings and lemonade or water, and reaches the shops in, for example, the 0.33-litre can that the amendment also cites as an example.[1] The alcohol for vodka is obtained from potatoes, grain or other agricultural raw materials.[5] If the category disappears, the orders are missing for the suppliers too: for producers of cans and flavourings, for distilleries and for the farmers whose grain is processed there.
Nobody has quantified how large this damage would be. That too is part of the impact assessment that is missing. Andreas W. Herb calls it massive damage because 2004 showed that such a duty can take a whole group of drinks off the market.
All the figures on the alcopop duty from 2004 to 2025, the three charts and the five steps that a government willing to learn would take now are set out with sources in the guest commentary.
The video only loads once you start it. It does not play by itself, and it does not measure who is watching.
CHECK
What was checked before publication
- The author provided the video on 15 November 2026. We have only reduced it in size for the web, to 1024 × 576 pixels and H.264; picture and sound are otherwise unchanged. All scenes have been viewed and checked against the guest commentary; the sound track was not listened to.
- Differences in the picture: at 10:40 the old upper limit of 2.8 million euros still appears; correct is 2.7 million, and the guest commentary has been corrected accordingly. The image “collected 0” simplifies: in 2025 revenue stood at minus 237,000 euros because more was refunded or offset than collected. For the new duty rate the video shows “−45%”; the coalition parliamentary groups speak of just under 45 per cent, and the figure in the amendment yields 45.4 per cent.
- In the video but not in the guest commentary: the 26,673 hospital cases of 2012 appear exactly like this in the table of the Federal Institute for Public Health. “1 bottle of vodka = 17 alcopops” fits a 0.7-litre bottle at 37.5 per cent and alcopops of 0.275 litres at 5.5 per cent; the video does not state size or strength. The planned 12 million euros of net additional revenue a year are the difference between 42 million euros of alcopop duty and 30 million euros less spirits duty in the 2004 bill.
- The party whip and the suppliers do not appear in the video. On these points the text documents: Article 38 of the Basic Law word for word, the Bundestag’s timetable, the warning from the industry association BWS, and the raw materials of vodka under the European spirit drinks regulation. Nobody has put a figure on the damage to the suppliers, and neither have we; the text says so. “Reduced to wards” (entmündigt) and “massive damage” (Riesenschaden) are the author’s assessments.
- The finance ministry and the coalition parliamentary groups were not asked for comment.
SOURCES
Sources
Every number in the text leads to its source. The origin is given at each entry: official, media report, trade association, institute or data portal. Titles stay in the original language, so that each document can still be found.
[1] Deutscher Bundestag, 12.11.2026
hib 935/2026: Finanzausschuss stimmt Verbrauchsteuer-Änderungen zuOfficial source↑ back to the text
[2] Deutscher Bundestag, abgerufen 15.11.2026
Haushalt 2027: Ablauf der Beratungen (abschließende Beratung 24. bis 27. November 2026)Official source↑ back to the text
[3] Bundesministerium der Justiz, abgerufen 15.11.2026
Grundgesetz, Artikel 38Official source↑ back to the text
[4] Deutscher Bundestag, 13.11.2026
Drucksache 21/9229: Beschlussempfehlung und Bericht des Finanzausschusses zum Antrag 21/8637, Vorabfassung (Seite 6)Official source↑ back to the text
[5] Europäische Union, 17.04.2019
Verordnung (EU) 2019/787 über Spirituosen, Anhang I Nummer 15: WodkaOfficial source↑ back to the text
[6] about-drinks, 09.11.2026
Alkopopsteuer: BWS warnt vor dem Aus einer GetränkekategorieMedia report↑ back to the text
[7] Deutscher Bundestag, 09.11.2026
Anhörung des Finanzausschusses zum Haushaltsbegleitgesetz 2027Official source↑ back to the text
[8] Bundesinstitut für Öffentliche Gesundheit (BIÖG), Stand 2025
Krankenhauseinweisungen wegen Alkoholvergiftung, 10- bis 24-Jährige, 2000 bis 2023 (nach der Krankenhausstatistik des Statistischen Bundesamts)Official source↑ back to the text
CORRECTIONS
Corrections
No corrections since publication on 15/11/2026. Every substantive change appears here with its date, reason and previous wording.
This page is opinion. Our fact checks are not.